200 W. Madison St. | Suite 2670 | Chicago, IL 60606 | Directions
DeBofsky, Sherman & Casciari, PC
Call Now 312-702-1842
800-237-5182 Toll Free
We Return Calls The Same Day.

January 2016 Archives

What is "appropriate equitable relief"?

The ERISA statute contains a provision that permits a large universe of potential claimants to seek "appropriate equitable relief."  29 U.S.C. Sec. 1132(a)(3).  Over a series of rulings the Supreme Court has wrestled with the meaning of that term. Historically, courts of equity were limited in the remedies they could provide litigants who came before such courts.  But with a growing recognition that monetary damages were sometimes necessary to allow recovery when a wrong had been committed, the courts in England and then in America permitted courts of equity to award money damages.  Finally, in 1938, the distinction between courts of equity and courts of law was blurred as the divided bench was joined together.

Aetna and the Courts

Aetna Life Insurance Company has attracted significant judicial scorn of late in the manner in which it adjudicates disability benefits.  Two recent decisions are illustrative - Jalowiec v. Aetna Life Ins. Co., 2015 WL 9294269 (D. Minn. December 21, 2015) and Granville v. Aetna Life Ins. Co., 2015 WL 9026025 (M.D. Pa. December 15, 2015).  In Jalowiec, which involved a disability insurance claimant who suffered from daily debilitating headaches, a benefit claimant was denied long-term disability insurance benefits despite certification of his disability by several treating doctors.  The court criticized Aetna for its reliance on reviewing doctors who engaged in a selective consideration of the evidence and who never consulted with the treating doctors to seek clarification of their opinions. 

  • super Lawyers
  • AV - Lexis Nexis - Martindale Hubbell - Preeminent - For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability
  • AVVO - Have No Legal Fear
  • BBB | A+ Rating
  • American Academy Of Trail Attorneys | Premier 100 | 2015 | AATA

Tell Us About Your Issue Today

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Email Us For a Response

Office Location:

DeBofsky, Sherman & Casciari, PC
200 W. Madison St., Suite 2670
Chicago, IL 60606

Toll Free: 800-237-5182
Phone: 312-702-1842
Fax: 312-929-0309
Chicago Law Office Map

Office Location