The ubiquity of forum selection clauses which mandate that disputes over benefits be litigated in locations inconvenient to most workers is undermining ERISA. It has increasingly become a problem for employees who have claims under their employer’s benefit plans that, instead of being able to seek redress where they live, have to travel hundreds, if not thousands, of miles to litigate these cases.

Chief Judge Ruben Castillo of the Northern District of Illinois has put the matter to rest. In Harris v. Metro. Life Ins. Co. et al., No. 1:15-cv-10299 (N.D. Ill., July 11, 2016) our firm, together with Ryan Rich of the law firm of Wham & Wham, defeated a motion to transfer a claim involving a life insurance dispute from Illinois to Houston, Texas. Judge Castillo ruled that forum selection clauses can be contrary to ERISA’s stated purpose of protecting plan participants and beneficiaries. He wrote:

“Employers and the insurance companies that administer plans are, for the most part, corporations with access to the resources necessary to defend suits in the districts where their beneficiaries work. . . . Beneficiaries, however, are frequently disadvantaged parties. . . . If forced to sue across the country or not at all, it would not be surprising if many were priced out of pursuing their rights.”

This ruling represents a significant victory for workers seeing protection of their right to receive promised employee benefits.

Related Articles

Behavioral health ruling supports benefit claim appeals

Litigating health benefit claim denials is extremely challenging for plaintiffs. Especially under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act — where many cases are decided under the arbitrary and capricious standard of review that upholds an insurance claim denial so...

Why do health insurers deny claims?

When you are ill and a doctor recommends a course of treatment, you naturally assume that your health insurer will reimburse the cost.  That is not always the case, though, and it is not uncommon for benefits to be denied, especially if the costs are high.  Examples...